by Randall CraigFiled in: Blog, Make It Happen Tipsheet, Media, Social Media, ViewpointTagged as: Accountability, Control
Should social media be regulated and controlled? Should hardware and network providers be forced to open a one-way window for authorities to monitor the flow of conversation? These questions are once again being asked, as supposedly “civilized” societies erupt into violence, riots, vandalism, and hooliganism.
In these cases, rioters changed the marketing concept of a flash-mob – a seemingly spontaneous song and dance event – into a crash mob – something more sinister. Social media was used by the rioters to pinpoint where and when a new area was to be targeted – and sadly, people responded.
Note that I am not conflating two very different groups: those who are in a non-violent march, and rioters who burn businesses and vandalize public property.
Beyond the argument for public order, proponents of regulation point out that governments already scan all phone and email conversations for issues of public safety and security. And in the private sector, emails are routinely scanned as well. Scanning encrypted Smartphone messages using a back door is merely putting this platform at parity with the others.
Notwithstanding these points, there are a number of arguments that suggest regulation and control are inappropriate, and ultimately unnecessary:
Quite separately, beyond all of these arguments, is the countervailing argument about whether the social platforms themselves should be subject to more stringent legislation, specifically in the area of privacy, data ownership, the use of the platforms for political manipulation, and “fake news”. A strong argument can be made on all of these fronts, and we’re beginning to see the stirrings of change.
I am not advocating the use of Social Media for unlawful activity, and believe fundamentally that anyone who breaks the law should be prosecuted to the full extent of that law. And those who use questionable business practices should be exposed and suffer commercial loss. But restricting – and losing – freedom of expression exclusively in one communication channel is inappropriate, and because of crowd-sourced justice, unnecessary.
The debate over regulation of these platforms, particularly with respect to privacy and data access, will likely affect everyone who uses them. This week, review your own organization’s approach in this area, beyond what is required through legislation (CCPA, GDPR, CASL, etc), and ask whether you can do even better.
Does this topic resonate? Reach out to Randall: he can present it to your group. (More presentation topics)
Download Randall’s professional credentials: Speaker credentials one-sheet or Management Advisory credentials.
@RandallCraig (Follow me for daily insights)
www.RandallCraig.com: Professional credentials site.
Each week, get Randall’s 60-second action-oriented insights on building your business. Curious? Read 600+ past articles.
If you are interested in receiving these each week (there is no cost), fill in your name and address below.
Contact us for more on Randall’s topics, availability, and audience fit.