Skip navigation

BLOGTen Tests: Can Your Website Live Through One More Year?

by Randall CraigFiled in: Blog, Make It Happen Tipsheet, Marketing, WebTagged as: , ,

How long do you keep your car?  Some people swap their car every 2-3-4 years, while others keep them for ten, and run them into the ground.  There are pros and cons to both strategies, and endless arguments about which is best: older cars have higher maintenance costs, sport some rust, and look dated.  But there are no monthly payments.

How long should you keep your website before swapping it for a new one?  Here are ten key questions that can help:

  1. Does it generate leads (or registrations) at the level you expect?  Every marketing channel needs to pull its weight: if the web is not doing so, then there needs to be a change.
  2. Is your blog still separate from your website?  To improve search engine rankings – and expose users to your static content – your website and blog need to be completely integrated.
  3. Is the site built on an “open” social platform, such as WordPress?  30% of all sites are built on this platform, for good reason: It’s free, it’s a social platform, and you’re not locked into a vendor’s proprietary system.  And there are 50K+ plug-ins that extend the functionality to do whatever you want.
  4. Are the pictures dated , or are they stock photography?  Is there video on the site?  Visuals give users the best clue to your relevance, and engage at an emotional level.
  5. Do site statistics show that users arrive on the site, then rarely click through to other pages?  This indicates poor page layout, poor content, and poor information architecture.  They expected something, and were either frustrated finding it – or disappointed in what they found.
  6. No mobile or tablet version of the site?  In some cases, the majority of users access the site on the go:  why frustrate them with a site that only looks good on a huge screen? (Read about Responsive Design.)
  7. Does your website’s look and feel reflect your real-world branding?  Websites should reflect what your brand aspires to be: does your website do this, or does it reflect a real-world brand from several years ago?
  8. Is your website connected to – and powered by – your systems?  Old-style sites are disconnected from internal systems; new sites tightly connected to both CRM (Customer Relationship Management), Marketing Automation, and Supply Chain/ERP systems.
  9. Do you get feedback that the site looks stale, is hard to find information on, or doesn’t “do” what they want?  It takes effort to complain, so listening carefully  – and doing something about it – makes sense.
  10. Are you satisfied with your site’s search engine ranking?  The site’s initial construction plays a significant role in how well it ranks: no amount of after-the-fact money paid to so-called SEO experts can fix a site that isn’t built with SEO from the ground up.


What grade does your site get on each of these questions?  While you may not need to re-do your website immediately, as each year passes, the site’s grades will continually worsen.  How long will it be before your site completely fails?  Planning for that time (this year/next year/the following year) isn’t such a bad idea.

Bonus question #11:  Check out the websites for your top three competitors: how does yours stack up?  If it is seriously out-classed, then re-doing your website should be a high priority – even if your answers to the other ten questions all seemed OK.

An offer:  Interested in direct feedback on your website and strategy?  I can be reached at, or directly at 416-918-5384.

Does this topic resonate? Reach out to Randall: he can present it to your group.  (More presentation topics)
Download Randall’s professional credentials: Speaker credentials one-sheet or Management Advisory credentials.

Content Authenticity Statement: 100% original content: no AI was used in creating this content.

@RandallCraig (Follow me for daily insights) Professional credentials site.



Randall Craig

Contact us for more on Randall’s topics, availability, and audience fit.

Back to top